I was invited to speak last evening at the Sideshow Reading Series by Sinclair Sexsmith, who co-hosts the Queer Literary Carnival. The event’s theme was masks. Here’s what I had to say:
May God bless you with discomfort at easy answers, half truths, and superficial relationships, so that you may live deep within your heart.
May God bless you with anger at injustice, oppression, and exploitation of people, so that you may work for justice, freedom and peace.
May God bless you with tears to shed for those who suffer from pain, rejection, starvation, and war, so that you may reach out your hand to comfort them and to turn their pain in to joy.
And may God bless you with enough foolishness to believe that you can make a difference in this world, so that you can do what others claim cannot be done.
So, when Sinclair asked me to read today, I was actually going to read a piece from my personal blog called “Men and Masks in Porn.” It was about the fact that in most of the porn I sought out, or found, when I was younger men are literally masked, not often for the sexual excitement of the thing but to hide their identity. We’re told that that is how men resonate with porn, that that would let us put ourselves in their places. That didn’t really do it for me at all.
And then, as I was thinking about what to say when I was speaking up here today, I kept getting drawn back to that Baptist proverb, that religious quote, because religion is one of the most powerful forces that exist in human history. Many people say it is the most powerful force, but it is in fact second only, I think, to sex. Not even religious guilt can stop or suppress any kind of human desire. I mean, there’s way more than enough news stories about…that.
So now, I understood the kind of sex that I wanted to have when I was really young, when I was about 10. And I started to look at pornography when I was 10, I found the Internet at that age, and I knew even then that it would be about 8 years or so before even the things that I wanted would be legal for me to have.
In fact, it’s still not legal for me to have some of the things that I want. I joined public sexuality communities at 18. I’m not allowed to consent to certain activities I’d like to consent to. Several people want to make certain things—sodomy, for example—illegal. And I know that for some of you in the audience today, it’s not even legal to be who you are. Many of you are forced to compromise half of yourselves—one half or another—just by putting M or F on any number of government forms.
So I’m thinking about all that as I’m growing up, and as a teenager I’m finding various representations of what I’m told I should want. And so I’m watching porn, and—this is me at like, 15 or 16, or 17, or 18 or so—I’m masturbating to it, and my dick is hard in my hand, and I’m crying because it’s not resonating, it’s not what I actually want, it’s not me there.
I think I’ve become so good at seeing what I want to see. In fact, you know, when I look at porn sometimes I change the genders around in my head. As a sexually submissive guy myself, I look at a lot of BDSM porn, a lot of women bottoms, and I’ll change the genders around in my head. When I see a woman tied up, I think, “It’s okay, I’ll just imagine them as a guy, someone like me.” Or when I see men, I’m like, “What are their faces like?” Because, again, masks. So I’ve become so good at seeing what I want to see that instead of seeing what there is, it’s become difficult for me to see the world as it is, and to take off my own lens. I think that’s probably one of the first masks that I’ve been almost traind to put on, out of my own desire.
And the more I looked at porn the more I realized I really wasn’t interested in seeing images of sexuality that aroused me, I was much more interested in seeing images of sexuality that reflected mine, so I could connect with them and see myself represented in that image and have a validation that I actually exist, that other people are like me there.
So I started to create spaces. One of the projects that I run is a website called MaleSubmissionArt.com and it was really designed around this idea: “You cannot be what you cannot see.” So I started to ask people to send me images of male submissiveness and masculinity in a submissive sexuality context. And the responses I got to it were absolutely astonishing. Some of the responses were from submissive women, which I could never have dreamed of getting. Here’s one of them:
I just wanted to thank you. I am a young woman and even though I’ve known I was submissive for quite a while, I’ve had a hard time reconciling that with my strong personality. Your comments, though, have inspired me to go looking for a dom willing to work as hard for me as I’ll work for them. I’m pretty sure you’ve changed my life for the better and I sincerely appreciate it. Thank you.
This desire to create spaces where we’re represented, I think, is common to many of us and many of us are trying to forge what I believe is a very new morality. One in which behavior towards other people is really geared not towards how we would like to be treated but on how they, themselves, would like us to treat them. I realize that’s a radical concept to some people but I think it’s very important and that’s not how we’re told we should behave.
About many of the spaces I’ve created, many submissive men have told me–you know the kind, a little creepy, not really very well-suited to public spaces, kind of hard to talk to–many of them have said, “Thank you for writing the things that you do. There aren’t many men who speak about the things you speak about.” They seem very lonely to me.
In their pain, I found a lot of validation because I understand that and I’m, truly, very lonely. When they thank me for what I write I understand the importance of my work. Having created those spaces, I really felt like I needed to distance myself from the very communities I went out to join at 18–they weren’t the spaces for me–in order to create new spaces.
I run an Internet talk show called Kink On Tap (at KinkOnTap.com). One of the responses that I got from there in another email was someone who wrote to me and said:
You’ve brought me more than a bit of peace on [the subject of my sexuality]. It’s nice to know that I’m not alone. Even though I was told over and over in my childhood that being anything other than the average, normal, baptist girl was a bad thing, reading your blogs and listening to Kink On Tap disproves all of that and I’m delighted to say a small amount of my own self-hatred is beginning to wane. And for that alone, I thank you so much.
So, people often ask me why I do the stuff that I do. And to that I’ve started answering with this question, which is: “What would you do after you’ve given up? After you’ve given up on having a sexually satisfied life? On having what you want?” My answer to that is anything you need to do to stay alive.
The correspondences that I get keep me alive when I feel like I’ve despaired. And I feel like I’m making people’s lives better. That’s the only currency I think I have—it’s not money, it’s not friendship, it’s not loyalty, it’s not sex—it’s doing. Actually doing. Action. So this new morality based not on commandments we’ve received but on affirmations we define for ourselves, I think, is how I keep myself alive and how I hope others will do the same, changing the world for the better.
People say changing the world is hard, that it’s a difficult thing to do. I think that’s not true. I think many of you in the audience by your mere existence here are changing the world. And it’s not changing the world that’s hard, it’s staying alive to do the work that’s difficult.
So what I want more than anything else in the world is to find other people like myself. People who are bored by complacency, who are exhausted by inaction, and who are stimulated by that discomfort. Because I think no one’s sexual rights—not one person’s—are assured unless all people can have the consensual relationships of their own choosing.
So if nothing else, for the love of love, reach out to someone and tell them that they are not alone. Connect with people so that they feel less alone. Those emails literally keep me alive. Email a friend and tell them about this reading series, encourage them to come out here, because too many people still think that they are alone when they are not.
by BD
13 Oct 2010 at 12:06
I didn’t see your email anywhere on the site, so I’m writing in the comments. If there is another way of contacting you please let me know.
I’m trying to figure out how to connect with other BDSM partners. I grew up in a fundamentalist home, so I can’t really turn to anyone in my social circle, and the women I’m meeting – though very attractive and sweet – aren’t bent toward this type of thing.
I just moved to LA, so I’m sure there are others in the city or groups of some kind, but I wouldn’t know how to find them – and personally, I’m not ready to go public with that part of my life yet. What is the best way to go about finding partners who are into this?
by maymay
13 Oct 2010 at 12:27
I’m not an advice columnist, but I’d tell you to find a local group, or you find people online. You can’t find others without making yourself known to them, without being at least partly public. Good luck.
by treesa
14 Oct 2010 at 10:00
you’re right, you’re right, you’re right. it isn’t the change that’s hard, it’s dealing with the world that needs it–and the expectations of inaction and complacency. fuck that noise.
and thank you for posting the stream of sideshow, I’m on the left coast and have always wanted to see it… and now I can! I especially appreciate your honesty as a speaker, and the acknowledgement that there is power in not only being seen but -seeing- others like ourselves as well, especially in a society where we are supposed to be stimulated by images we encounter, but not necessarily connect with them. so, thank you maymay!
(hmm…is the stream of the whole show posted somewhere on the ‘nets?)
by maymay
14 Oct 2010 at 10:10
Thank you so much for saying so, treesa.
Yes, the entirety of the evening is recorded and online. Currently, it’s only available via Ustream, in three parts:
Enjoy. :)
by RogueBambi
21 Oct 2010 at 22:47
It breaks my heart to read how alone you feel you are. I’m oceans away, but I send positive energy anyway. You’ve made me realize many things about my sexuality as a submissive woman – and the sexuality and the morals of others – and I thank you for always being so straightforward. You are trusted, believed in and read also in Europe.
It’s been eye-opening to see how you’ve been crusified for trying to bring awareness of the diversity of sexuality to the public. Sexuality (and gender, like you mentioned) is such a huge part of our humanity and you can’t just clip that away and lead your life like it’s not there. I’m an educator and a writer and have had some breakthroughs – one of my students bringing their lesbian girlfriend to school, for example. What would they gain of being denied acceptance and information? It won’t go away.
Thank you, Maymay.
Pingback
by How to maintain a not-fucked-up D/s relationship « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
28 Oct 2010 at 23:10
[…] has made it easier for other people to live the sexually fulfilling lives they want is sometimes the only thing keeping me alive these days. So I was more than a little chuffed to read that Thumper drew from a post I wrote in […]
Pingback
by Sex is like breathing; sex education is like breathing education « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
10 Nov 2010 at 14:42
[…] Ongoing right now is the Scarleteen sex education blog carnival, coordinated by the always-active AAG. Many sex bloggers write erotically about the sex they have, but I often don’t. One reason for my reticence on the subject is because, believe it or not, sex is a personally painful topic. […]
Pingback
by This is me, here, now. And I just wanted you to know. « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
26 Nov 2010 at 21:59
[…] quite some time. It’s really hard not to be guarded when one feels unsafe—be it physically, emotionally, or legally—being in public view. And I am pretty unabashed about being in public […]
Pingback
by Conversation with Clarisse Thorn about Kink, Inc.’s “hymen-gate” « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
13 Feb 2011 at 23:53
[…] occurred to me some time ago that the “creepy, old, pathetic submissive men” in the scene—the ones that open conversation with pompous self-abasement such as, […]
Pingback
by Kink.com’s correspondent incompetence or deliberate malfeasance? « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
22 Feb 2011 at 05:08
[…] of Kink, Inc. employees is a prerequisite for models, but a luxury for bloggers like me—and I can do without such luxuries. There’s only one other company of analogous size whose PR efforts are as skillful, and I was […]
Pingback
by It’s foggy today: how BDSM and sex can be emotional self-medication in a cruel world « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
11 Mar 2011 at 13:27
[…] “What would you do after you’ve given up on having the sex life you want?” I once asked. For many people—and on a personal level, notably submissive men with “sophisticated” gender identities—this is not a hypothetical question. And I am obscenely privileged for having the resources needed to merely identify this reality. […]
by Sunshine Love
28 Mar 2011 at 00:49
“And it’s not changing the world that’s hard, it’s staying alive to do the work that’s difficult.”
Ain’t that the truth…
by kinkylittlegirl
17 Apr 2011 at 22:31
I’m so sorry you’re so lonely, maymay, but I do understand. The work I’m doing about fighting abuse hasn’t exactly endeared me to a lot of people, as that topic is pretty much just as taboo in kink circles as many of the ones you’ve spoken about in this post.
It really is staying alive that’s hard. I’d never thought of it that way before, but it’s true.
Keep at things long enough, and you *will* create change.
The price can be really high, though, sadly enough, as you’ve intimated. Those of us who tilt at some of these windmills *have* to learn to find satisfaction in helping others, if it’s not already an inherent part of our personalities, as it fortunately is for me.
Pingback
by We are all victims, even the revolutionaries « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
20 Apr 2011 at 20:28
[…] We are all victims of our society, but none suffer more tragically than young people. And no suffering is more personal than our struggle for sexual freedom. […]
Pingback
by My unreal experience on the Kink, Inc. Armory Tour « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
02 May 2011 at 04:24
[…] someone like me went through when I viewed possibly the very same images by the same producers but responded with sobs instead of orgasms. In my more cynical moments, I feel like even that description is too kind: in actuality, most of […]
by TheWalkingRiot
15 Jul 2011 at 15:06
There are, in rare moments, times when words strung together in sentences turn into something else. They turn into something that tugs at you on a mental and emotional level that’s beyond being able to use words itself, and so you can’t explain it. Some chest-burning feeling that’s the big brother to the French sensation of “l’appel du vide”.
“‘What would you do after you’ve given up? After you’ve given up on having a sexually satisfied life? On having what you want?’ My answer to that is anything you need to do to stay alive.”
As a transgender person, that one was strong enough that I had to close the laptop and go crawl in the shower. Three days later, reading it still makes me cry.
Thank you.
Pingback
by On Letting The World Burn « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
19 Jul 2011 at 19:55
[…] even here, still alive—and still writing—in a poetic-literal sense. But it’s also why what I’ve come to call the Work will never be “done.” The day I stop getting emails like this on a regular basis is […]
Pingback
by Raging Chrysalis: The End of the Mute Submissive Masculine « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
02 Sep 2011 at 19:21
[…] smiled. “What would you do after you’ve given up on having a sexually satisfied life?” I asked […]
Pingback
by On Being Bondage Furniture « Maybe Maimed but Never Harmed
14 Dec 2011 at 21:58
[…] I couldn’t imagine what it would be like to expect exclusion, to predict ostracization. Then it happened with such disturbing regularity that I became unable to imagine what it would be like not to expect […]